Navigation


style="display:inline-block;width:728px;height:90px"
data-ad-client="ca-pub-6756631450701279"
data-ad-slot="5548827944">

SIFMA Testifies Before Congress on Behalf of ETNs

A representative of the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (SIFMA) testified before the House of Representatives today that a bill under review that would modify the tax treatment of exchange traded notes would do more harm than good to the investment community. Leslie B. Samuels from the law firm of Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton, said on behalf of SIFMA that "We are concerned that H.R. 4912 would impose an overly complex tax regime that would single out prepaid derivative contracts for unfavorable treatment by requiring that investors include amounts in income that they have no right to receive—and may never receive."

He pointed out that mutual funds and ETNs are different types of financial instruments, and should be treated as such. One key difference is that ETN holders have no right to any cash distributions, and ETNs do not confer ownership of any asset to the holder.

Another key point made by Samuels is that, “the difference between the tax treatment of ETNs and mutual funds is based on a fundamental rule of tax law that an investor who has the full right to take cash income, but elects not to, is subject to taxation on that cash as if it were received. Taxpayers cannot avoid tax on cash they could put in their pockets simply by using it for other purposes. This is why investors in mutual funds are taxed currently on distributions from the mutual fund even if they choose to reinvest the cash. In short, investors in mutual funds are taxed on distributions because they have the choice of keeping the cash or reinvesting it.”

Because ETN holders do not have any right to cash income from the ETN, any tax imposed on unrealized gains would be a tax on "phantom" income that may never be realized.

Samuel's final point is that ETNs should be treated like prepaid derivative contracts since they are similar in structure. These instruments have been in existence for 15 years, and are not taxed like debt, therefore any attempts to tax them or ETNs as such would be unfair.

ETNs have been under fire from the mutual fund industry as they have become more popular, with firms like Vanguard asking Congress to tax ETNs in the same manner as ETFs and mutual funds to remove one of the advantages of ETNs. As Samuels pointed out today on behalf of SIFMA, these claims are flawed, and most likely based on concern over a new competitor for investor funds, rather than an interest in fairness.

payday loan

eogxppir payday loan CirPmO pay day loans >:-OOO Payday UK klegZ

quickquid

ywwhrina quickquid FpGDpy payday loans 0380 cash advance online >:]]

pay day loan

cheap viagra online

buy viagra

viagra online

payday loans

ayxrlsp payday loans 0098 payday loans Canada 6110 quickquid QvUswq

payday loans

tbpfzky payday loans acyNQO payday Canada :-O short term loan >:-OOO

pay day loans

afalkifs pay day loans 7222 payday loans lPIMfh pay day loan 6601

fast payday loan

pounds till payday

Quick Quid

wafbynn Quick Quid KPtRv payday loans %-[[[ pay day loan %-[[[

instant Payday Loans

viagra

finknau viagra wQZHU cialis hbcna cheap generic cialis pvpTur generic viagra 9489

no fax payday loans

payday loan

pounds till payday

Payday UK

kayloqed Payday UK 0049 payday loans 2785 payday Canada 8]]]

fast payday loan

payday loans online

payday loans online

payday loans

czfdyfuf payday loans 8125 cash advances >:-[ payday loans %-[[[

personal loans

rtuxbsz personal loans 0406 pay day loans 1157 same day loan 1254

pounds till payday

viagra

pay day loans

rtgiya pay day loans 3737 payday loans >:]] cash advances ihoCi

cialis

ezrsltfe cialis lznXMS viagra 8949 how to buy viagra >:-[ buy cialis online now =-]

fast payday loan

zhsywsp fast payday loan ilsAsD payday cash 9700

quick payday loans

ajkzqen quick payday loans nrKvR Payday advance >:-OOO

cash advance

payday advance

payday loans

payday loans UK

payday advance

pay day loan

idvaqxt pay day loan 9266 no fax pay day loan >:-[ Payday UK SENYfB

payday cash

cheap almond and cucumber peel off mask

Payday UK

gyrfxbqb Payday UK >:]] no fax payday loans WCZZf pay day loan %-[[[

Bad Credit Loans

payday cash

oxdrqbi payday cash 2888 payday loan 9498 no fax pay day loans jkbgdU

payday loan

iasrazbz payday loan >:-OOO cash advance 5006 payday loan Canada okPTfJ Bad Credit Loans 4988

payday advance

Payday advance

zpapwz Payday advance 2944 payday loan oPUtY pay day loan 7164 Cash Advance >:]]

payday loans

hwyefcu payday loans JWzDMo payday loans hYksR payday loan %-[[[ payday loans :-O

Quick Quid

ctktjy Quick Quid 2635 pay day loan yOMWH pay day loans jglpaH cash advance :-O

pay day loans

duhwxyz pay day loans CCLbV get money >:]] cash advances EHCXi cash advance qYHxBP

bad credit loans

payday loan

fast cash advance

payday loans